Investigating Workers' Compensation Fraud: What Tennessee Employers and Insurers Need to Know
Workers' compensation fraud is one of the most expensive problems Tennessee employers and insurers face, and one of the most underinvestigated. The reason is understandable: most employers feel uncomfortable questioning whether an injured employee is being honest. The relationship involves trust, and the optics of conducting surveillance on someone who says they've been hurt are difficult. So claims get paid. Accommodations get made. And sometimes — not always, but often enough to matter financially — the injury that's being compensated isn't what the claimant is representing it to be.
At Delator Group and Bird's Eye Investigations, we conduct workers' compensation fraud investigations throughout Tennessee for employers, third-party administrators, and insurers who have reason to believe a claim doesn't add up.
The Scope of the Problem
The Tennessee Bureau of Workers' Compensation, housed within the Department of Labor and Workforce Development, maintains oversight of the workers' comp system and has its own fraud prevention unit. But the volume of claims that genuinely warrant investigation far exceeds the capacity of any state agency.
Workers' compensation fraud takes several forms. Claimant fraud is the most relevant for PI-assisted investigation: a worker who has sustained a genuine injury but is exaggerating its severity, a worker who has staged an injury or falsely reported one, or a worker who has recovered to the point where they could return to work but is continuing to collect benefits.
What Triggers an Investigation
Not every workers' compensation claim warrants investigation. The claims that warrant investigation are those where something specific doesn't add up: a reported mechanism of injury inconsistent with the physical circumstances, medical findings inconsistent with the claimant's described functional limitations, inconsistencies in the claimant's statements across different interactions, social media activity inconsistent with reported limitations, a pattern of claims from the same individual, or information from coworkers suggesting the claimed injury wasn't the result of a workplace incident.
How Surveillance Investigation Works in Workers' Comp Cases
The primary investigative tool is mobile surveillance. An investigator from Delator Group or Bird's Eye Investigations observes and documents the claimant's physical activities and capabilities in their day-to-day life outside of the medical or employment context.
The investigator must operate from public vantage points, observe and document accurately without alerting the subject, and capture clear, timestamped video that makes what the subject is doing unambiguous.
What investigators are looking for is activity inconsistent with the claimant's reported limitations. A claimant who reports being unable to lift more than ten pounds is documented loading heavy equipment into a truck. A claimant who reports being confined to bed is documented playing in a recreational sports league. A claimant who reports severe and constant back pain is documented installing a roof over a weekend. The video speaks for itself.
The Role of Social Media Investigation
Before any field surveillance is conducted, Delator Group and Bird's Eye Investigations conduct a thorough open-source intelligence review of the claimant's public social media presence. Claimants who are exaggerating injuries often haven't considered that their public social media activity documents their actual functional level. A claimant who reports debilitating limitations but posts videos of outdoor activities or home projects on public social media has created a significant credibility problem for themselves.
What Happens With the Investigation Results
The findings are delivered in a written report with supporting media documenting the investigator's methodology, the locations and times of surveillance, what was observed, and the specific inconsistencies between the claimant's stated limitations and the documented activity.
The employer or insurer then has several options. Under T.C.A. § 50-6-134, workers' compensation fraud is a criminal offense in Tennessee, with penalties that escalate based on the amount involved. The findings can support denial or modification of the claim, criminal referral, or civil recovery for benefits paid during the period of documented fraud.
What Employers Should Not Do
Don't conduct surveillance yourself or have your supervisors do it. Don't tip off the claimant. Don't make fraud allegations without documented evidence. Do involve your attorney from the beginning.
If You Have a Claim That Doesn't Add Up
Tennessee businesses and insurers dealing with workers' compensation claims that raise questions should take those questions seriously. Delator Group and Bird's Eye Investigations handle these investigations with discretion and produce documentation that is directly usable in claims decisions and legal proceedings.
---
Delator Group and Bird's Eye Investigations are licensed private investigation firms serving clients throughout Tennessee. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.